This question is about In-App Purchase. This is an inquiry from one of our customers. We have set up a free trial. This is your first time using the service, but you have stated that you have been charged. Document. https://developer.apple.com/documentation/appstorereceipts/is_trial_period 「You can use this value to determine whether the specific record is in a subscription trial period. If a previous subscription period in the receipt has the value "true" for either the is_trial_period or is_in_intro_offer_period keys, the user is not eligible for a free trial or introductory price within that subscription group.」 Our expectation is that is_trial_period is true. Receipt is not contain is_trial_period : true or is_in_intro_offer_period : true. Only one case has occurred. Other customers are no problem.

I have several ObjC based apps in the App Store and used to validate the receipt file inside the app in my code, and then reject it with exit(173) if it's invalid, which did trigger macOS to update the receipt if possible. This isn't working any more in recent macOS versions, where the user is instead just told that the app is damaged, and they need to re-install it manually. Which sucks. So I wanted to update my code. I read about SKReceiptRefreshRequest, which is supposed to re-download and install the receipt file, if I understand it correctly. I implemented the code but now have trouble verifying that it works as intended, and does this in a user friendly way. I found in my tests that macOS now caches the receipt in ~/Library/Caches/com.apple.appstoreagent/fsCachedData and then hardlinks the file into the app. BTW: Sadly, this also requires that the app is located on the startup volume or the system will refuse to install the receipt, which wasn't a requirement in past times. Now, if the receipt is already present in the cache folder, then my code works - the receipt gets re-linked. But what if the cached receipt isn't there, yet? Such as that the user had copied the app from another Mac over to a freshly installed Mac? In the past, when the user then launched the app on the new Mac, he'd be prompted to login to the MAS and if that worked, the receipt would get installed and the app launched. Basically, the question is: What if the receipt validation fails in my app and I request a new receipt, but the user has not yet logged into MAS (e.g. new computer)? To simulate this, I logging out of the MAS and TestFlight, deleting all copies of the app and then run the app that I had copied from another Mac where it was authorized with a valid receipt for that device. If I do this with the old version that uses exit(173), I get these two messages in macOS 15.2: The second one is especially terrible because it shows the translocated path, which the average user surely get quite confused, and then maybe even search in vain for the app in there and get frustrated. But that's out of my hands. Sigh. Now, that was proving that the old method with exit(173) isn't working any more and needs to be changed in my apps. Since I'm still developing (testing) this new behavior, the app is therefore not in the MAS yet - the only way for me to test this is to use TestFlight. However, running a Testflight app copied from another Mac leads to this error: That is not helpful in simulating what would happen if this app was released in the MAS. This won't let me find out what happens if my app is run on a Mac where the receipt fails and I ask it to load it via SKReceiptRefreshRequest and if the user is NOT yet logged into the MAS account for this purchased app of his/hers. That leaves only one option: Release the app with untested code and hope for the best. Contrary to this new behavior, the old method did let me test this easily because I would just use the special App Store tester account with the MAS app, i.e. the built MAS app would, when I launched it locally, request for a login and I'd provide my tester's account. But this isn't available any more, apparently. What a mess.

Hi, My app has been on the store for a few months now with a few updates. Now I plan a major update that will affect the structure of core data itself (key attribute replaced by relationship). I see no other way than asking the users to delete and reinstall the app to reset all data and start it as new. In a previous update I provided users the possibility to backup their data in a file so they can restore it with the future release. Is there a better way than using the "What's new in this version" section to pass the message to the users ?

Hello everyone, I want to set up subscriptions but I'm having problems testing them. Indeed, when I use the storekit file to view the subscriptions it works, I see the subscriptions and I can subscribe in XCODE mode. However, I'd like to go further and test with server notifications. So I removed the storekit file from the scheme, but I can't retrieve the products. The application doesn't retrieve any products.. I've been stuck on it for 2 weeks... I checked the contracts and put in all the information last Friday and everything is validated. I tested it in testflight mode, and it doesn't recognize any products! Just so you know, I use the original API for maximum compatibility.

Dear Reviewers/Apple Team/Community, We have trying to submit our app continuously for review and being rejected continuously by Apple. Our app works perfectly fine in TestFlight using the same ID apple is using. We have also provided recorded video of the testing in TestFlight to Apple reviewer. However, despite our requests below things are not done: Before testing the in-app purchase subscription are not being approved, despite us requesting the same every time during submissions. At times we are getting snapshots under error category, where everything is correct even from Apple testing. We have no other way but to explain, give snapshots, give videos to Apple to help them understand how to test the app. We have requested the reviewers multiple times for a call, but we got a call only 1 time. We are not sure what is the way we can get to talk with the reviewer and understand from them the issue they are facing. Can anyone please help us out? Below is one example, it was given it us under error category, where even with apple standard, the purchase is successful. Can someone help us out plz.

I have some questions regarding the specifications of the receipt information that can be obtained from https://developer.apple.com/documentation/appstoreserverapi/get_transaction_info. When a subscription is newly purchased, it is expected that the purchaseDate should reflect the time of purchase and should not be later than this time, such as an hour after the purchase. Is this understanding correct? We observed a phenomenon where, when a user purchased a new subscription between 17:30 and 20:00 JST on November 3, 2024, the purchaseDate in the received receipt was delayed by one hour compared to the actual purchase time. Is this a specification or an issue? When validating the receipt for a newly purchased subscription, if the purchaseDate reflects a time later than when the purchase was made, should I regard the user as having subscription rights at the time of validation?

I have 6 Mac App Store apps. They're all upfront paid, with no IAP, and they've all used the same on-device Mac App Store receipt validation code for years, which returns 173 in main() if there's not a valid receipt. Incidentally, the apps are entirely Objective-C. I've just learned that if I compile an app with Xcode 16 and the macOS 15 SDK, I get the alert "exit(173) Not Available" when the app returns 173 on macOS 15 Sequoia. The rest of the alert text says, "The exit(173) API is no longer available. You can use Transaction.all or AppTransaction.shared to verify in-app purchases instead." I have several questions: Why was this done? Where is this behavior change documented? What are my options, given the above description of my apps?

The application has changed from paid purchase to free use. We need to obtain the previous player's purchase records to unlock the paid content. //Here is the code for the client to obtain the player's payment information: NSURL * receiptURL = [[NSBundle mainBundle] appStoreReceiptURL]; if ([[NSFileManager defaultManager] fileExistsAtPath:[receiptURL path]]){ NSData *receiptData = [NSData dataWithContentsOfURL:receiptURL]; NSString *receiptUrlString = [receiptData base64EncodedStringWithOptions:NSDataBase64EncodingEndLineWithLineFeed]; NSLog(@"requestAppStoreReceipt receiptUrlString = %@", receiptUrlString); } else { // 如果凭证为空，则再发一次凭证请求 SKReceiptRefreshRequest *refreshReceiptRequest = [[SKReceiptRefreshRequest alloc] initWithReceiptProperties:@{}]; refreshReceiptRequest.delegate = self; [refreshReceiptRequest start]; NSLog(@"requestAppStoreReceipt 如果凭证为空，则再发一次凭证请求！"); } //The following is the server-side parsing code: Path filePath = Path.of("SubscriptionKey_ABCDEFGHIJ.p8"); String encodedKey = Files.readString(filePath); Environment environment = Environment.SANDBOX; AppStoreServerAPIClient client = new AppStoreServerAPIClient(encodedKey, keyId, issuerId, bundleId, environment); String appReceipt = "MIIcs..."; ReceiptUtility receiptUtil = new ReceiptUtility(); String transactionId = receiptUtil.extractTransactionIdFromTransactionReceipt(transactionReceipt); System.out.println(transactionId); if (transactionId != null) { long now = System.currentTimeMillis(); TransactionHistoryRequest request = new TransactionHistoryRequest() .sort(TransactionHistoryRequest.Order.DESCENDING) .revoked(false) .productTypes(List.of(TransactionHistoryRequest.ProductType.CONSUMABLE)); HistoryResponse response = null; List<String> transactions = new LinkedList<>(); do { String revision = response != null ? response.getRevision() : null; response = client.getTransactionHistory(transactionId, revision, request, GetTransactionHistoryVersion.V2); transactions.addAll(response.getSignedTransactions()); } while (response.getHasMore()); Set<InputStream> rootCAs = Set.of( new FileInputStream("AppleComputerRootCertificate.cer"), new FileInputStream("AppleIncRootCertificate.cer"), new FileInputStream("AppleRootCA-G2.cer"), new FileInputStream("AppleRootCA-G3.cer") ); Long appAppleId = 1234567899L; // appAppleId must be provided for the Production environment System.out.println(transactions.size()); SignedDataVerifier signedPayloadVerifier = new SignedDataVerifier(rootCAs, bundleId, appAppleId, environment, true); for (String notificationPayload : transactions) { try { AppTransaction payload = signedPayloadVerifier.verifyAndDecodeAppTransaction(notificationPayload); System.out.println(payload); } catch (VerificationException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } } } //Return result analysis: JWSTransactionDecodedPayload{originalTransactionId='2000000641683476', transactionId='2000000641683476', webOrderLineItemId='null', bundleId='', productId='', subscriptionGroupIdentifier='null', purchaseDate=1719566962000, originalPurchaseDate=1719566962000, expiresDate=null, quantity=1, type='Consumable', appAccountToken=null, inAppOwnershipType='PURCHASED', signedDate=1728885967093, revocationReason=null, revocationDate=null, isUpgraded=null, offerType=null, offerIdentifier='null', environment='Sandbox', storefront='CHN', storefrontId='143465', transactionReason='PURCHASE', price=6000, currency='CNY', offerDiscountType='null', unknownFields=null} We have develop according to the following document on our end： https://developer.apple.com/documentation/foundation/nsbundle/1407276-appstorereceipturl#4098404 https://developer.apple.com/documentation/appstoreserverapi/get_transaction_info/ https://developer.apple.com/documentation/appstoreserverapi/data_types We would like to know if the solutions in the document can be used to solve the problems we encountered? Is there a problem with our method of parsing bills that prevents us from obtaining the necessary information?

Hello! Since October 2, we have observed a problem with the renewal of subscriptions. We have not changed anything, but the receipts no longer have the information whether a valid subscription exists after the subscription was actually automatically extended. The subscription status can then be queried correctly via verify Receipt. Has anything been changed to the receipts from Apple? PS: we know that StoreKit1 is deprecated and we should switch to StoreKit2 asap.

Hello, I have a customer who keeps getting an "app is damaged" error for a freshly downloaded app from the Mac App Store. The logs show the following lines: standard 12:58:40.390872+0200 storeuid Receipt Validation (at.EternalStorms.Yoink) Signature Check: PASS Bundle ID Check: PASS Bundle Version Check: PASS GUID Check: PASS Expiration Check: PASS standard 12:58:40.391649+0200 storelegacy StoreLegacy: Failed to perform in-line receipt renewal for application at path /Applications/Yoink.app : '(null)' The Mac in question is running macOS 12 Monterey - curiously, the customer has another Mac with that same system version and there it works just fine. What can be done to make this work again? Thank you, – Matthias

Hello, I'd like to find out if macOS Sequoia's MAC Address randomization affects the data (specifically, MAC addresses) we receive from I/O Kit. For context, I'd like to find out if it affects my Mac App Store receipt validation code in any way. Thank you, – Matthias

Hello, I hope to find out more about how AppTransaction works on macOS, specifically about its internet connection requirements: if I use this to validate that the app is a legit purchase from the Mac App Store, I would not want it to have an always-on requirement just to validate. Does AppTransaction require the user to always be online for AppTransaction.shared ? When an app is downloaded from the Mac App Store, is the data needed for AppTransaction automatically embedded during that download, or is that data downloaded upon first launch of the app, therefore requiring an internet connection at launch time? Once the data/receipt has been downloaded by AppTransaction, is it cached until the app's next update, or is it cleared at some time during the version's life and needs to be re-downloaded, therefore requiring an internet connection at launch? Where is that receipt/data stored? Also, if you don't mind me sneaking in this non-related but sort of related question, in terms of receipt validation: Does macOS Sequoia's MAC address rotation feature affect receipt validation in any way when using IOKit? Thank you kindly, – Matthias

Since today, we are receiving reports from several customers on iPadOS17.x and iPadOS18 that their app runs in 'demo' mode. This can only happen if the purchase receipt is not found and this also shows in the log file they sent us. We can also reproduce it on an officially installed version of our app, but not when run from Xcode. Is anyone else experiencing this?

Hello, Our project did not approve because of the in-app purchase did not work, i need help! (Guideline 2.1 - Performance - App Completeness) We've done it several times in TestFlight and sorry the in-app purchase connection doesn't work, before getting the final output the in-app purchase debugging is done correctly in editor unity, i wanted to make sure before testing the in-app purchase whether the bank account form Should it be approved? Because of the bank account form, I could not find the code and branch, so I sent a ticket to financial support and sent the bank documents and I am waiting for the answer. Regards,

Hello team, It'd be very grateful if you give us some advice for our issue. It's about receipt verification in production environment. Details are as follows. User tried to purchase consumable IAP in production environment. Price is charged for IAP. After that, tried to verify receipt using the receipt of the transaction, but it failed with an error message. "21004 The shared secret you provided does not match the shared secret on file for your account." This error occurs only sometimes, not always. Most of purchase succeeded without this issue. For your reference, we've sold subscription IAP but now stopped to sell subscription IAP since last year. And we've been transferred this app from other iOS team last year. Our iOS developer account have configured both primary shared secret and app-specific shared secret for this app. I've found the similar issue with ours. https://forums.developer.apple.com/forums/thread/746202 Thank you. Best regards

Dear Apple Development Team, I would like to draw attention to certain aspects of working with Server Notifications for In-App Purchases that could be improved to enhance development convenience and API efficiency. 1. Lack of Information on Non-Consumable Purchases in Server Notifications Currently, Server Notifications do not provide information about non-consumable purchases. This creates certain inconveniences when validating such purchases on the server. It would be extremely useful to have the ability to verify non-consumable purchases in the same way as subscriptions. Moreover, there is currently no way to obtain information about the amounts paid for non-consumable purchases, even with additional API requests. This limitation significantly complicates financial reporting and analytics for apps that utilize non-consumable purchases. While we can obtain information about the amount paid by the user for a subscription, we have no equivalent capability for non-consumable purchases. Adding this information to Server Notifications or providing an API endpoint to retrieve it would greatly improve our ability to track and analyze non-consumable purchase data without relying on client-side reporting. 2. Inconsistency in Token and Signature Handling There is some inconsistency in the approaches to authentication and verification between various Apple APIs. For example: When using Sign In with Apple, the approach with keyid is applied for JWT verification. In Server Notifications for In-App Purchases, certificate information is repeatedly duplicated in each notification. This leads to the need to implement different methods of JWT verification depending on the API being used. Additionally, the current approach with Server Notifications results in data redundancy: the useful payload is about 1.5 KB, while repetitive certificate information takes up about 17 KB in each notification. Unifying authentication and verification approaches across different APIs could significantly simplify development and improve data processing efficiency. We would appreciate consideration of these suggestions for API improvement. This could substantially simplify developers' work and increase the efficiency of integrating Apple services into applications. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

It seems that starting from around 2024-08-20T10:28:00 UTC, both the "trialPeriod" and "introOfferPeriod" fields are set to true in the receipt data of free-trial subscriptions. Before that time only trialPeriod was set to true while introOfferPeriod was false. Just want to confirm whether this is an expected and permanent change? Thanks.

I want to get MacOS Version from Objective-C build for iOS Apps to run on Apple Silicon Mac. Because AppStore In-App Purchase on Apple Silicon Mac had issues on MacOS version 13.0 and was fixed at version 13.3.1. I need to know the exact version of the MacOS to prevent users from buying In-App Purchases. I found that I can get iOS version that the app is emulating on and assume MacOS version from iOS version. But I think it's not 100% guaranteed way, because no documentation says anything about it. Is there a way to get MacOS Version in iOS Apps running on Apple Silicon Mac?

Hi, Our application offers 3 non-renewing subscriptions. I have integrated the necessary code, and our App Store Account Paid Agreement status is Active. Transactions are successfully completed in the sandbox environment. However, I am facing difficulties with server-side validation. The /verifyReceipt API is deprecated, and I need an alternative method for server-side validation. The Apple documentation is quite confusing, and I couldn't find any articles related to the new approach for server-side validation. I would greatly appreciate it if you could provide a detailed guide on how to perform server-side validation with the new method. Thank you in advance.

We have some questions regarding the receipt fields: Our receipt validation refers to this document: Validating Receipts on the Device(https://developer.apple.com/documentation/appstorereceipts/validating_receipts_on_the_device). We would like to know if preorder receipts can also be validated using the methods outlined in the above document. If so, may I ask which ASN.1 Field Type corresponds to the preorder_date_ms? Additionally, we found other receipt fields in this document: Receipt Fields(https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/releasenotes/General/ValidateAppStoreReceipt/Chapters/ReceiptFields.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/TP40010573-CH106-SW1). If possible, it would be appreciated if someone could supplement the definitions of each ASN.1 Field Type.