I have spent a long time refactoring lots of older Swift code to compile without error in Swift 6. The app is a v3 audio unit host and audio unit. Having installed Sonoma and XCode 16 I compile the code using Swift 6 and it compiles and runs without any warnings or errors. My host will load my AU no problem. LOGIC PRO is still the ONLY audio unit host that will load native Mac V3 audio units and so I like to test my code using Logic. In Sonoma with XCode 16... My AU passes the most stringent AUVAL tests both in terminal and Logic pro. If I compile the AU source in Swift 5 Logic will see the AU, load it and run it without problems. But when I compile the AU in Swift 6 Logic sees the AU, will scan it and verify it passes the tests but will not load the AU. In XCode I see a log message that a "helper application failed to run" but the debugger never connects to the AU and I don't think Logic even gets as far as instantiating the AU. So... what is causing this? I'm stumped.. Developing AUv3 is a brain-aching maze of undocumented hurdles and I'm hoping someone might have found a solution for this one. Meanwhile I guess my only option is to continue using the Swift 5 compiler. (appending a little note just to mention that all the DSP code is written in C/C++, Swift is used mainly for the user interface and also does some offline thready work )

Hello! I used the Apple CA Playthrough example code that pipes audio between devices. It uses AudioUnit callbacks to pipe the input to an output device, and I created a system equalizer with it - however users reported it stopped working in macOS 15. I am getting the error HALPlugIn.cpp:552 HALPlugIn::DeviceGetCurrentTime: got an error from the plug-in routine, Error: 1937010544 (stop) for the output device and no sound coming out of the speakers. The error only occurs when using a virtual device as an input, not using the microphone. First I thought the problem was in the loopback driver, but it also does not work with other loopback drivers like Blackhole. STEPS TO REPRODUCE Install a virtual device, for example "brew install blackhole-2ch" and run the CAPlayThrough example code (you need to add Mic Permission in the info.plist). Then set your system audio output to the virtual device, select the device as input in CAPlayThrough and hit start. You should see the error in console. My question: What did change in macOS 15 that could cause this? Is it something with the new permission handling maybe?

Hi everyone, I’m encountering a crash in my app and need help understanding what’s causing it and how to resolve it. As stated in the crash report, the issue is caused by exceeding the system-wide per-process port limit. Can you tell me how to locate and identify why this is happening? Below are the full report of the crash log: crash.log Summary of Crash: ------------------------------------- Translated Report (Full Report Below) ------------------------------------- Incident Identifier: B509FF2B-C8D8-4E9F-B664-E24464CFD5F8 CrashReporter Key: b390cfe931a83efde49bd8b523023a275b55ef64 Hardware Model: iPhone14,2 Process: MyApp [22515] Path: /private/var/containers/Bundle/Application/F73212A7-4CB9-485A-A8B7-8114F4E9A9AB/MyApp.app/MyApp Identifier: com.beeasy.app.id.enterprise Version: 3.41.38-ID-MySDKMemory-12261114 (3.41.38-ID-MySDKMemory-12261114) Code Type: ARM-64 (Native) Role: Foreground Parent Process: launchd [1] Coalition: com.beeasy.app.id.enterprise [515] Date/Time: 2024-12-29 01:29:48.3023 +0800 Launch Time: 2024-12-26 16:38:36.7895 +0800 OS Version: iPhone OS 16.6.1 (20G81) Release Type: User Baseband Version: 2.80.01 Report Version: 104 Exception Type: EXC_RESOURCE (SIGKILL) Exception Codes: 0x000000000001c1d6, 0x0000000000000000 Termination Reason: PORT_SPACE 14123288431433990614 (Limit 115158 ports) Exceeded system-wide per-process Port Limit Triggered by Thread: 64 Thread 64 name: AURemoteIO::IOThread Thread 64 Crashed: 0 libsystem_kernel.dylib 0x20ce5eca4 mach_msg2_trap + 8 1 libsystem_kernel.dylib 0x20ce71b74 mach_msg2_internal + 80 2 libsystem_kernel.dylib 0x20ce71e4c mach_msg_overwrite + 540 3 libsystem_kernel.dylib 0x20ce5f1e8 mach_msg + 24 4 libEmbeddedSystemAUs.dylib 0x238bb2148 void* caulk::thread_proxy<std::__1::tuple<caulk::thread::attributes, AURemoteIO::IOThread::IOThread(AURemoteIO&, caulk::thread::attributes const&, caulk::mach::os_workgroup_managed const&)::'lambda'(), std::__1::tuple<>>>(void*) + 556 5 libsystem_pthread.dylib 0x22dcda6b8 _pthread_start + 148 6 libsystem_pthread.dylib 0x22dcd9b88 thread_start + 8

I'd like to know: Let's say there's a backgrounded app which has microphone access, such as Signal or SoundHound or Shazam. It's established that these apps are allowed to record audio in the user's environment even after being backgrounded, seemingly for as long as they want and even upload that sound data. But can they ALSO continue recording even while another app that is in the foreground is using the microphone, such as the Phone app or Signal?

I've been generating new Audio Unit Extension apps with Xcode 16 (and newer), and although they generally work initially, it is easy (although I'm not sure how to do it reliably) to cause the app to no longer be able to instantiate the audiounit. Generally the call to AVAudioUnit.findComponent fails and SimplePlayEngine hits the fatalError("Failed to find component with type...") In the most recent project, merely adding files to the extension (without making any use of them) caused it to go off the rails. If I "Archive" the app+plugin, there is no audio unit extension in the bundle. If I switch to the audiounit extension and build it it's fine. If I look at the build folder in Library/Developer/Xcode/project_folder the extension_name.appex is there. Any ideas? If I can coax an unmodified audio unit extension project to exhibit this behavior I'll attach it here. Right now what I have has code I don't want to share.

I have a werid case that shouldn't happen according to https://forums.developer.apple.com/forums/thread/706390 I have an audio unit which runs in FCP and I want it to launch a sandboxed app as a child process. If I sign the child app with just "com.apple.security.app-sandbox" entitlement it crashes with SYSCALL_SET_PROFILE error. According to the article referenced above: "This indicates that the process tried to setup its sandbox profile but that failed, in this case because it already has a sandbox profile." This makes sense because audio units run in a sandboxed environment (in AUHostingService process). So I added "com.apple.security.inherit" to the entitlements plist and now I get "Process is not in an inherited sandbox." error. According to the article referenced above: "Another cause of a trap within _libsecinit_appsandbox is when a nonsandboxed process runs another program as a child process and that other program’s executable has the com.apple.security.app-sandbox and com.apple.security.inherit entitlements. That is, the child process wants to inherit its sandbox from its parent but there’s nothing to inherit." And this doesn't make sense at all. The first error indicates the child process is trying to create a sandboxed environment within a parent sandboxed environment while the second error indicates there's no a parent sandboxed environment... I specifically checked the child process has "com.apple.security.app-sandbox" and "com.apple.security.inherit" entitlements only. If I remove all entitlements from the child process it launches and runs fine from the audio unit plugin. And if I remove "com.apple.security.inherit" but leave "com.apple.security.app-sandbox" I can successfully launch the app in standalone mode (in Finder). For the testing puroses I use a simple Hello World desktop application generated by XCode (Obj-C). Does anybody have an idea what can be the reason for such a weird behavior?

Hi! I am creating a aumi AUv3 extension and I am trying to achieve simultaneous connections to multiple other avaudionodes. I would like to know it is possible to route the midi to different outputs inside the render process in the AUv3. I am using connectMIDI(_:to:format:eventListBlock:) to connect the output of the AUv3 to multiple AvAudioNodes. However, when I send midi out of the AUv3, it gets sent to all the AudioNodes connected to it. I can't seem to find any documentation on how to route the midi only to one of the connected nodes. Is this possible?

For an upcoming update of one of my apps, I’m facing an issue: The .rate parameter of a AVAudioUnitTimePitch allows me to slow down an audio track without any issues: setting .rate to 0.7 or 0.8 results in an almost perfect playback without changing pitch. However, whenever the .rate parameter is greater than 1 (e.g. 1.1 or 1.15), I’m starting to hear audio artifacts (“flattering”) in the audio output which is not so nice (even at .overlap = 32). Intuitively, I’d’ve thought that speeding up the file should contain less artifacts than slowing it down?? I’ve tried different sample rates (44.1 kHz and 48 kHz), but same result. Grateful for any input on this 🙏

I’m working on a memo app that records audio from the iPhone’s microphone (and other devices like MacBook or iPad) and processes it in 10-second chunks at a target sample rate of 16 kHz. However, I’ve encountered limitations with installTap in AVAudioEngine, which doesn’t natively support configuring a target sample rate on the mic input (the default being 44.1 kHz). To address this, I tried using AVAudioMixerNode to downsample the mic input directly. Although everything seems correctly configured, no audio is recorded—just a flat signal with zero levels. There are no errors, and all permissions are granted, so it seems like an issue with downsampling rather than the mic setup itself. To make progress, I implemented a workaround by tapping and resampling each chunk tapped using installTap (every 50ms in my case) with AVAudioConverter. While this works, it can introduce artifacts at the beginning and end of each chunk, likely due to separate processing instead of continuous downsampling. Here are the key issues and questions I have: 1. Can we change the mic input sample rate directly using AVAudioSession or another native API in AVAudio? Setting up the desired sample rate initially would be ideal for my use case. 2. Are there alternatives to installTap for recording audio at a different sample rate or for continuously downsampling the live input without chunk-based artifacts? This issue seems longstanding, as noted in a 2018 forum post: https://forums.developer.apple.com/forums/thread/111726 Any guidance on configuring or processing mic input at a lower sample rate in real-time would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

Somehow I have a corrupted audio plugin authentication problem. I’m on a silicon Mac M1 and two audio plugins that were installed and working will now not authenticate. The vendors both are unable to troubleshoot and I think the issue is a corrupted low level file. One product authenticates correctly when I created a new user but another plugin only authenticates on the original user account and not on the newly created user. Reinstalling the plugins and the Mac OS does not fix the issue. Any thoughts?

I'm running into an issue where in some cases, when the AUHostingServiceXPC_arrow process is shut down by Logic, the process is terminated abruptly without calling AP_Close on all of the plugins hosted in the process. In our case, we have filesystem resources we need to clean up, and having stale files around from the last run can cause issues in new sessions, so this leak is having some pretty gnarly effects. I can reproduce the issue using only Apple sample plugins, and it seems to be triggered by a timeout. If I have two different AU plugins in the session, and I add a 1 second sleep to the destructor of one of the sample plugins, Logic will force terminate the process and the remaining destructors are not called (even for the plugins without the 1 second sleep). Is there a way to avoid this behavior? Or to safely clean up our plugin even if other plugins in the session take a second to tear down?

After investing more than a week into getting a bunch of audio unit projects converted into app + appex + framework, they all are now correctly loaded in-process in the demo host app that is part of Xcode's template. However, Logic Pro adamantly refuses to load them in-process. Does Logic Pro simply not do that ever, or is there some hint or configuration my plugins need to provide to enable that? If it is unsupported, will it be supported in some future version of Logic? The entire point of investing that week was performance, which is moot if it is impossible to test the impact of loading in-process in a real-world usage scenario.

When we tested the audio quality of our VoIP App, we found that when the iOS18.0 device was played with AirPods Pro 2, we could hear noises similar to peak clipping and distortion, especially when the sound source played was loud and high-pitched. Here is the device information we tested: Model: iPhone 16 Pro Max, iPhone 15 Pro System version: iOS 18.0 (22A3354) Bluetooth headset model: AirPods Pro 2 Bluetooth firmware version: 6F8 We tested multiple apps (including phone calls, FaceTime, Zoom, WeChat, Tencent Meeting), and they all had the above noise problem. We also found two phenomena: If we use the same iOS 18 device to connect HUAWEI FreeBuds Pro or FreeBuds 2, there is no such noise problem; If we use an iOS 17 device to connect to the same AirPods Pro 2 for testing, there is no such noise problem; Therefore, we suspect that it is caused by the compatibility problem between iOS 18.0 and AirPods firmware 6F8. The firmware version of our AirPods Pro 2 is 6F8, which was released on June 26, and iOS 18.0 was released on September 16. Maybe they are not very compatible. I hope that subsequent firmware updates can fix this problem.

Hi! I have an AVAudioSequencer with some AVMusicTracks that are filled with AVParameterEvents. If I toggle the isMuted property of a track, it will instantly mute when changed to true. However, after turning the muting to false, the events will only triggers on the next round of a loop and not instantly. Is this intended behaviour, and is there some way to get the events to trigger immediately after toggling the isMuted to be false?

Hello, We have noticed an issue with SoundRecognition that causes glitching with our AudioUnit setup in Smule. Input and output frame sizes are inconsistent. Input frame size does not match [AVAudioSession sharedInstance].IOBufferDuration My best guess is that SoundRecognition influences the input frame size and not the output frame size. To reproduce use the example app here: https://github.com/MarkoGill/SoundRecognitionBug Hardware/OS iPhone 14 Pro on iOS 18 -> Experiences the problem iPhone 11 on iOS 18 -> Experiences the problem iPhone 15 on iOS 18 -> Not experiencing the problem Reproduction Steps Enable Sound Recognition (Settings > Accessibility > Sound Recognition > On) Enable a Sound for detection (Sounds > Dog > On) Open the example app with headset (it routes input to output) Notice glitching occurs Check the logs. Record and Playback buffer sizes vary Example Log: AU input sample rate: 48000.000000 AU output sample rate: 48000.000000 hardware sample rate: 48000.000000 hardware buffer size: 1104.000000 updated record frame counts: 1024 updated playback frame counts: 1104 Notes: You can disable Sound Recognition, restart the app, and playback behaves correctly.

I've got a bunch of AudioUnit projects approaching release, and am attempting to build an installer for them. All are based on the AudioUnit template in Xcode 14. What actually governs how the system detects an AudioUnit? The instructions I have seen say that the built .appex should be renamed to have the extension .component and installed into /Library/Audio/Plug-Ins/Components/ - great, I am able to build a signed installer that does that (i.e. strip out the built Application project that is part of the AudioUnit template but useless to, say, a Logic Pro user), include the .appex that declares the plugin and embeds a Framework that contains the actual code (so it can be loaded in-process). auval -l does not show it after running the installer, nor does Console show anything logged suggesting that it was found but malformed or something like that. Meanwhile, simply building the project causes auval -l to show an install of it in the build directory, and I have noticed that if I delete that, auval -l would still show the plugin installed, but now in the location I exported an archive of the project (!!). What black magic is this? However, deleting both the recent build and the archive, after running the installer, and there is no indication that AudioComponentRegistry even sees the copy of it in one of the two locations actually documented to be valid install locations for an AudioUnit. I have, however, installed one third-party free AUv3 which installed into /Library/Audio/Plug-Ins/Components/ Am I misunderstanding something about how this works? Is there some string other than AudioComponentRegistry I should filter on in Console that might provide a clue why my AudioUnit installed there is not picked up? Must I ship the semi-pointless Application that is part of the Xcode template project, and whatever magical mechanism detects it when I build will work its magic on end-users' machines? Or could the problem be that the Framework with the actual code under Contents/Frameworks inside the audio unit, rather than installed independently into /Library/Frameworks?

I've got a bunch of Audio Units I've been developing over the last few months - in Xcode 14 based on the Audio Unit template that ships in Xcode. The DSP heavy-lifting is all done in Rust libraries, which I build for Intel and Apple Silicon, merge using lipo and build XCFrameworks from. There are several of these - one with the DSP code, and several others used from the UI - a mix of SwiftUI and Cocoa. Getting the integration of Rust, Objective C, C++ and Swift working and automated took a few weeks (my first foray into C++ since the 1990s), but has been solid, reliable and working well - everything loads in Logic Pro and Garage Band and works. But now I'm attempting the (woefully underdocumented) process of making 13 audio unit projects able to be loaded in-process - which means moving all of the actual code into a Framework. And therein lies the problem: None of the xcframeworks are modular, which leads to the dreaded "Include of non-modular header inside framework module". Imported directly into the app extension project with "Allow Non-modular Includes in Framework Modules" works fine - but in a framework this seems to be verboten. So, the obvious solution would be to add a module map to each xcframework, and then, poof, they're modular. BUT... due to a peculiar limitation of Xcode's build system I've spent days searching for a workaround for, it is only possible to have ONE xcframework containing a module.modulemap file in any project. More than that and xcodebuild will try to clobber them with each other and the build will fail. And there appears to be NO WAY to name the file anything other than module.modulemap inside an xcframework and have it be detected. So I cannot modularize my frameworks, because there is more than one of them. How the heck does one work around this? A custom module map file somewhere (that the build should find and understand applies to four xcframeworks - how?)? Something else? I've seen one dreadful workaround - https://medium.com/@florentmorin/integrating-swift-framework-with-non-modular-libraries-d18098049e18 - given that I'm generating a lot of the C and Objective C code for the audio in Rust, I suppose I could write a tool that parses the header files and generates Objective C code that imports each framework and declares one method for every single Rust call. But it seems to me there has to be a correct way to do this without jumping through such hoops. Thoughts?

Hello! The new lower latency support for AirPods in Game Mode is impressive, but I'm not sure of the best way to handle the transition into/out of Game Mode while audio is playing. In order to lower the latency, the system appears to drop some number of samples, with the result being a good deal less latency. My use case is macOS where it's easier to switch in/out of the fullscreen game (a simple swipe left), thus causing more issues for Game Mode since the audio is playing the entire time. It would be nice if offscreen games could remain in game mode, but I understand not wanting to give developers that control. Are there any best practices for avoiding or masking the audio glitch caused by this skip-ahead? Is there a system event I can receive to know when Game Mode is about to be enabled or disabled, where I could perhaps fade out the audio? My callback checks the inTimestamp->mSampleTime value to detect gaps, but it only rarely detects a Game Mode gap, even though the audio skip-ahead always happens. BTW, I am currently only developing on macOS (15.0) and I'm working at a low level with AudioUnit callbacks and a SpatialMixer. I am not currently using any higher-level audio APIs. And here's a few questions I don't necessarily expect answers to, but it doesn't hurt to ask: Is there any additional technical details about how this latency reduction works, or exactly how much of a reduction is achieved (or said another way, how many samples are dropped)? How much does this affect AirPods battery life? And finally, is there a way to query the actual latency value? I check the value for kAudioDevicePropertyLatency but it seems to always report 160ms for AirPods. Thanks!

Hello everyone, I'm new to Core Audio and still haven't found my footing. I'm learning how to capture audio from the default device, using Audio Units. On my MacBook, the default audio input is mono. But when I write a piece of code to capture audio using AUHAL, I'm discovering that I need to provide an AudioBufferList with two channels, not one. Also, when I try to capture audio from an audio interface with 20 audio inputs, I must provide an AudioBufferList with two channels, and not with 20 channels. To investigate the issue, I wrote a small diagnostic program, which opens the default audio device and probes it for the number of channels. Depending on which way I'm probing, I'm getting different results. When I probe the stream format, I'm getting information that there is 1 channels. But when I probe the input audio unit, I'm getting information that there are 2 input channels. Here's my program to demonstrate the issue: // InputDeviceChannels.m // Compile with: // clang -framework CoreAudio -framework AudioToolbox -framework CoreFoundation -framework AudioUnit -o InputDeviceChannels InputDeviceChannels.m // // On my system, this prints: // Device Name: MacBook Pro Microphone // Number of Channels (Stream Format): 1 // Number of Elements (Element Count): 2 #import <AudioToolbox/AudioToolbox.h> #import <AudioUnit/AudioUnit.h> #import <CoreAudio/CoreAudio.h> #import <Foundation/Foundation.h> void printDeviceInfo(AudioUnit audioUnit) { UInt32 size; OSStatus err; AudioStreamBasicDescription streamFormat; size = sizeof(streamFormat); err = AudioUnitGetProperty(audioUnit, kAudioUnitProperty_StreamFormat, kAudioUnitScope_Input, 1, &streamFormat, &size); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error getting stream format\n"); exit(1); } int numChannels = streamFormat.mChannelsPerFrame; UInt32 elementCount; size = sizeof(elementCount); err = AudioUnitGetProperty(audioUnit, kAudioUnitProperty_ElementCount, kAudioUnitScope_Input, 0, &elementCount, &size); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error getting element count\n"); exit(1); } printf("Number of Channels (Stream Format): %d\n", numChannels); printf("Number of Elements (Element Count): %d\n", elementCount); } void printDeviceName(AudioDeviceID deviceID) { UInt32 size; OSStatus err; CFStringRef deviceName = NULL; size = sizeof(deviceName); err = AudioObjectGetPropertyData( deviceID, &(AudioObjectPropertyAddress){kAudioDevicePropertyDeviceNameCFString, kAudioObjectPropertyScopeGlobal, kAudioObjectPropertyElementMain}, 0, NULL, &size, &deviceName); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error getting device name\n"); exit(1); } char deviceNameStr[256]; if (!CFStringGetCString(deviceName, deviceNameStr, sizeof(deviceNameStr), kCFStringEncodingUTF8)) { printf("Error converting device name to C string\n"); exit(1); } CFRelease(deviceName); printf("Device Name: %s\n", deviceNameStr); } int main(int argc, const char *argv[]) { @autoreleasepool { OSStatus err; // Get the default input device ID AudioDeviceID input_device_id = kAudioObjectUnknown; { UInt32 property_size = sizeof(input_device_id); AudioObjectPropertyAddress input_device_property = { kAudioHardwarePropertyDefaultInputDevice, kAudioObjectPropertyScopeGlobal, kAudioObjectPropertyElementMain, }; err = AudioObjectGetPropertyData(kAudioObjectSystemObject, &input_device_property, 0, NULL, &property_size, &input_device_id); if (err != noErr || input_device_id == kAudioObjectUnknown) { printf("Error getting default input device ID\n"); exit(1); } } // Print the device name using the input device ID printDeviceName(input_device_id); // Open audio unit for the input device AudioComponentDescription desc = {kAudioUnitType_Output, kAudioUnitSubType_HALOutput, kAudioUnitManufacturer_Apple, 0, 0}; AudioComponent component = AudioComponentFindNext(NULL, &desc); AudioUnit audioUnit; err = AudioComponentInstanceNew(component, &audioUnit); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error creating AudioUnit\n"); exit(1); } // Enable IO for input on the AudioUnit and disable output UInt32 enableInput = 1; UInt32 disableOutput = 0; err = AudioUnitSetProperty(audioUnit, kAudioOutputUnitProperty_EnableIO, kAudioUnitScope_Input, 1, &enableInput, sizeof(enableInput)); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error enabling input on AudioUnit\n"); exit(1); } err = AudioUnitSetProperty(audioUnit, kAudioOutputUnitProperty_EnableIO, kAudioUnitScope_Output, 0, &disableOutput, sizeof(disableOutput)); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error disabling output on AudioUnit\n"); exit(1); } // Set the current device to the input device err = AudioUnitSetProperty(audioUnit, kAudioOutputUnitProperty_CurrentDevice, kAudioUnitScope_Global, 0, &input_device_id, sizeof(input_device_id)); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error setting device for AudioUnit\n"); exit(1); } // Initialize AudioUnit err = AudioUnitInitialize(audioUnit); if (err != noErr) { printf("Error initializing AudioUnit\n"); exit(1); } // Print device info printDeviceInfo(audioUnit); // Clean up AudioUnitUninitialize(audioUnit); AudioComponentInstanceDispose(audioUnit); } return 0; } It prints: Device Name: MacBook Pro Microphone Number of Channels (Stream Format): 1 Number of Elements (Element Count): 2 I tried to set the number of channels to 1 on the input unit, but it didn’t change anything. After calling setNumberOfChannels(1, audioUnit), I’m still getting the same output. Note 1: I know that I can ignore one channel, etc, etc. My purpose here is not to "somehow get it to work", I already did that. My purpose is to understand the API, so that I'll be able to write code that handles any number of audio inputs. Note 2: I already read a bunch of documentation, especially this here: https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/technotes/tn2091/ - perhaps the channel map could help here, but I can’t make sense of it - I tried to use it based on my understanding but I only got the -50 OSStatus. How should I understand this? Is it that that audio unit is an abstraction layer and automatically converts mono input into stereo input? Can I ask AUHAL to provide me the same number of input channels that the audio device has?

Hello macOS gurus, I am writing an AUv3 plug-in and wanted to add support for additional formats such as CLAP and VST3. These plug-ins must reside in an appropriate folder /Library/Audio/Plug-Ins/ or ~/Library/Audio/Plug-Ins/. The typical way these are delivered is with old school installers. I have been experimenting with delivering theses formats in a sandboxed app. I was using the com.apple.security.temporary-exception.files.absolute-path.read-write entitlement to place a symlink in the system folder that points to my CLAP and VST3 plug-ins in the bundle. Everything was working very nicely until I realize that on my Mac I had changed the permissions on these folders from to The problem is that when the folder has the original system permissions, my attempt to place the symlink fails, even with the temporary exception entitlement. Here's the code I'm using with systemPath = "/Library/Audio/Plug-Ins/VST3/" static func symlinkToBundle(fileName: String, fileExt: String, from systemPath: String) throws { guard let bundlePath = Bundle.main.resourcePath?.appending("/\(fileName).\(fileExt)") else { print("File not in bundle") } let fileManager = FileManager.default do { try fileManager.createSymbolicLink(atPath: systemPath, withDestinationPath: bundlePath) } catch { print(error.localizedDescription) } } So the question is ... Is there a way to reliably place this symlink in /Library/... from a sandboxed app using the temporary exception entitlements? I understand there will probably be issues with App Review but for now I am just trying to explore my options. Thanks.