Sign In With Apple not working wit… | Apple Developer Forums

Developer Forums

Running the sample "Juice" app, which demos the Sign In With Apple flow, doesn't seem to work with Xcode 12 beta and iOS 14 beta on the simulator (worked fine on the non-beta versions and on a real device with iOS 14 beta).

Once the password for the device's Apple ID is entered, the wheel in the password field just keeps spinning. No error messages and nothing handed back over to the app from the ASAuthorizationController.

Anyone else seeing this problem ? Are there any workarounds ?

92k

Posted by

npvisual

Reply

Same problem here, any solution yet?

—
claoudj
facing the same issue in xcode 12.3 and simulator iOS 14.3

—
samsonfromgood
This is a complete joke... absolutely no comment by Apple on this... Apple doesn't care about its developers at all... The only solution: buy an iPhone!

—
jack241

Replies

Same here

xCodeVersion 12.5 (12E262)
SimulatorVersion 12.5 (961.1)
SimulatorKit 609
CoreSimulator 757.5

Posted by

darkhorse-dev

Same exact issue. xcode 12.4 simulator 12.4 ios 14 iphone 12

Posted by

bboldi

Dear Apple,

Can you please either fix the problem or tell your app review staff this issue exists. Each app I have launched in the last year or so has to go through a second review process because of this issue, it's very frustrating.

Kind regards, Tibout

Posted by

martibis

Same issue here. Infinite loading wheel after entering the password, no error message.

Posted by

louisdeveseleer

This is still an issue in Xcode 13 w/ iOS 15.

How do they expect us to build Apple Sign In apps if we can't run them on the simulator at all?

Posted by

ikaria

Still an issue. Can NOT sign in with Apple on the simulator. Has Apple ever tried to do this themselves?

Posted by

bryanfromardmore

Same Issue.

Posted by

Renanmgs

Same issue on Xcode 13 beta 3

Posted by

TS251

Did you fixed your problem?

Posted by

Sofy

Still relevant.

Not working

Posted by

AlexDremov

Same here, still a problem.

Posted by

Zacco

Another day, same problem on Xcode 12.5.1. It seems that Apple does not want us to use their "brand new" authentication feature.

Posted by

Sergey Marchukov

Same problem. We are in a Catch-22, as we are required to add Sign in with Apple to our app in order for it to be approved, however we have no good way of testing it with the simulator(s) on different devices.

Posted by

lightburn

Response from Apple:

Our engineers have reviewed your request and have determined that you are experiencing a known issue. (Workaround: Use a physical device.)

—
lightburn
Of course, we can use a physical device as a workaround. However, what is the point of using a physical device during development if App reviewers are going to review apps with a simulator and reject the apps if sign-in with apple workflow fails? Also, what if Sign in with Apple is required before proceeding to the main screen of the app?

This issue has been open for over a year and Apple just refuses to fix this one.

—
Dev1525

I don't care if Apple goes 2 years without fixing this, but it's totally idiotic from App Reviewers to reject updates when this is a problem directly from Apple.

Posted by

R8Manzo

I have the exact same issue where the spinner is infinitely looping after entering the password, no error, no callback.

Both on Xcode 12.5.1 and Xcode 13 Beta 4.

Apple, please fix it, it's really frustrating that you have to use a physical device, basically, for the whole development.

Sign in is always the first step in the App flow

Posted by

xmkevinchen