Sign In With Apple not working with Xcode 12 beta on simulator ?

App & System Services General
npvisual OP
Created Jun ’20
Replies 206
Boosts 4
Views 93k
Participants 176
Running the sample "Juice" app, which demos the Sign In With Apple flow, doesn't seem to work with Xcode 12 beta and iOS 14 beta on the simulator (worked fine on the non-beta versions and on a real device with iOS 14 beta).

Once the password for the device's Apple ID is entered, the wheel in the password field just keeps spinning. No error messages and nothing handed back over to the app from the ASAuthorizationController.

Anyone else seeing this problem ? Are there any workarounds ?
Replies  206
Boosts  4
Views  93k
Participants  176
Developer Tools Engineer OP
Apple
Jun ’20
Hi npvisual, thanks so much for the question! Could you please file a feedback assistant issue for this, and please comment back here with the FB number so we can get it in front of our Simulator team? Please attach the app you're running, and also please attach the output of sudo sysdiagnose as well as xcrun simctl diagnose. It would be best to run the app, try to sign in, let it get into the failure state, and then run these diagnose commands before attaching them to the feedback assistant issue. That way, we should have a better chance of seeing what might be going wrong. Thank you!!
3
npvisual OP
Jun ’20
Sure. Here's the FB number : FB7786750. I have attached the requested files to the issue.

As mentioned, you can use the "Juice" app, run it in the simulator with Xcode 12 Beta.
2
freter OP
Jul ’20
Can confirm this happens with the Juice sample app.

Environment:

  • Xcode 12.0b1

  • SimulatorKit 597.8

  • CoreSimulator 725.10

  • iOS 14.0

2
KINGandKONG OP
Jul ’20
Can confirm!

Actually "Sign In With Apple" in general does not run on iOS 14 Simulators. I have a full blown "Sign In With Apple" with backend server that runs smoothly on all iOS 14 DEVICES, but not the Simulator.

iOS 14 Simulators, once you sign in to Apple account in the Settings,

  • you can not Sign Out!!!!

  • no access to submenu: Name, Phone Number, Email

  • no access to submenu: Password & Security

5
npvisual OP
Jul ’20
Did another test with Xcode 12 beta 2 :

Xcode Version 12.0 beta 2 (12A6163b)
Simulator Version 12.0 (940.9.1)
SimulatorKit 597.8
CoreSimulator 725.10

Same issue
1
npvisual OP
Jul ’20
Also submitted FB7875260 to address the related issues that @KINGandKONG highlighted in one of the replies.
1
freter OP
Jul ’20
Still an issue with Xcode 12 beta 3.

  • Xcode Version 12.0 beta 3 (12A8169g)

  • Simulator Version 12.0 (940.12)

  • SimulatorKit 597.10

  • CoreSimulator 732.7

2
piers_ OP
Aug ’20
This is currently a massive blocker for me at the moment. Really hope this gets fixed in Beta 4.
3
freter OP
Aug ’20
Still not working in Xcode 12 beta 4.
2
freter OP
Aug ’20
Can repro this 10/10 on Xcode 12b4 when running on a Simulator running iOS 14 (using the Juice sample app). It works fine when running on a physical device (iOS 14 or lower), as well as when running on an iOS 13.4 Simulator.

I've filed FB8281892 with details.
2
npvisual OP
Aug ’20
This is a major blocker for any sort of development using "Sign In With Apple". An update would be really appreciated on FB7786750. Thanks.
2
naturaln0va OP
Aug ’20
I'm currently using Xcode 12.0 beta 4 (12A8179i) with the same issue.

This has been broken for me since the first Xcode beta. It's disappointing that this is still unusable mid-way through the beta cycle. Developing on a physical device isn't doable for everyone since it's not recommended to put the betas on devices not soley devoted to development.

I hope this is fixed in the next beta.
2
freter OP
Aug ’20
I can still repro this in the latest beta (Xcode 12 b5) on the Simulator.
2
OptionJedi OP
Aug ’20
Yep, button shows up, bug the sign in process goes into the infinite spinning wheel after I enter my apple ID credentials. Version 12.0 beta 5 (12A8189h)
2
KNLKN OP
Aug ’20
Three months and six beta releases and this still has not been fixed! Not even acknowledged as a known issue in the release notes. This is absurd. I can't imagine the developers have not been able to reproduce any of the bug reports submitted. Last time I will submit any bug report to apple.
7
mredig OP
Aug ’20
Experiencing this here in beta 6 as well. Such a crucial feature sitting this long (since beta 1 if I recall correctly) without so much as a mention does not inspire confidence.

I've reported with feedback and this is the ID: FB8533272

I also attached the sysdiagnose files as was requested of the OP as well.
0
Peer123123123123 OP
Aug ’20
Same problem here.

macOS 11 Beta 5
Xcode Beta 6
2
freter OP
Sep ’20
This is still an issue in Xcode 12.0 GM Seed. Here are my Simulator version numbers:

  • Version 12.0 (940.16)

  • SimulatorKit 597.13

  • CoreSimulator 732.17

When signing in on a Simulator, the progress spinner in the password field shows and never stops spinning. I used the Juice app to repro.
3
curiousgeorge123 OP
Sep ’20
Also not working for me. This is a significant blocker in our development environment

XCode 12 (12A7209)

Simulator
Version 12.0 (940.16)
SimulatorKit 597.13
CoreSimulator 732.17
2
ukaton OP
Sep ’20
This is also a significant blocker in our development and I have tested Apple Sign In. There's no way to see any errors since the activity indicator seems to hang and the console doesn't indicate any Authentication/Authorization errors.

About Xcode
Version 12.0 (12A7209)

About Simulator
iPhone 8+ (iOS 14) [Works on iOS 13]
Version 12.0 (940.16)
SimulatorKit 597.13
CoreSimulator 732.17
2
andreimatei OP
Sep ’20
Same problem here

About Xcode
Version 12.0 (12A7209)

About Simulator
iPhone 11 (iOS 14) [Works on iOS 13]
Version 12.0 (940.16)
SimulatorKit 597.13
CoreSimulator 732.17
2
IramRJ OP
Sep ’20
Hi @ukaton , any solution or tips ?
3
Seaver OP
Sep ’20
Now Xcode 12.0 is released and the issue is still here. Are we really expecting Apple support to take care of this?
4
Wuffkatz OP
Sep ’20
Have exactly the same issue (even with Xcode 12).
Hope this will be solved soon as this is a really huge blocker.
1
alexfr OP
Sep ’20
I confirm too that it is still happening with the XCode 12.0 release...
4
Sign In With Apple not working with Xcode 12 beta on simulator ?
First post date Last post date
 
 
Q