User Profile

I've submitted this as FB13628591 but I figure a forum post never hurts ;) I’ve discovered an issue with keyboard presentation when using .searchable in SwiftUI in iOS 17.4 beta 3, shown in this video (https://imgur.com/1hmM5u0) running this sample code. struct Animal: Identifiable { var id: String { return name } let name: String } struct ContentView: View { let animals: [Animal] = [.init(name: "Dog"), .init(name: "Cat"), .init(name: "Turtle")] @State var presentedAnimal: Animal? = nil @State var searchText: String = "" var body: some View { NavigationStack { List { ForEach(animals) { item in Button(item.name) { self.presentedAnimal = item } } } .sheet(item: $presentedAnimal) { item in Text(item.name) } .searchable(text: $searchText) } } } As of iOS 17.4, the behavior of the above code is that if you tap one of the list buttons to present a sheet while the keyboard is still presented, the keyboard will dismiss then represent once the sheet is presented. In the video, I tap the “Cat” button while the search keyboard is still presented. This is confusing, because the keyboard actually belongs to the presenting .searchable view, not the presented sheet. In all previous versions, the keyboard would dismiss and stay that way. That is the correct behavior. I’ve noticed this erroneously presented keyboard does not respond to calls to resignFirstResponder: let resign = #selector(UIResponder.resignFirstResponder) UIApplication.shared.sendAction(resign, to: nil, from: nil, for: nil)

I'd really like to be able to show List row swipe actions with text and an image, like in Mail.app: In my app, using the .swipeActions modifier on a list row, I have been unable to display both text and an image. It just displays the image. Here is my code: .swipeActions(edge: .leading, allowsFullSwipe: true) { Button { Task { await albumProvider.treatGridAsQueue(album: album) } } label: { Label("Play", systemImage: "play.fill") } Button { AlbumContextHandler.shared.handleTag(albumObject: album, session: nil, presentedSheet: $albumProvider.sheetToPresent) } label: { Label("Tag", systemImage: "tag.fill") { } } I have also tried various initializers on Button, including init(_:systemImage:action:), but none of them have worked. The strange thing is that very occasionally just the top row of a List will display the title and label the first time the swipe actions are displayed. Showing them a second time will just show the icons, as in my screenshot. I've also played around with .buttonStyles but haven't found those to make a difference. Any ideas?

I'm experiencing this issue on Sonoma beta 7 and Xcode 15 beta 8: FB13094612 -- MusicLibraryRequests are way slower on macOS than iOS The following code has massive speed differences on macOS than iOS, with macOS taking 3-7 seconds for each request and iOS taking 0.1 seconds or less. let start = Date() var artistAlbumRequest = MusicLibraryRequest<Album>.init() artistAlbumRequest.filter(matching: \.artistName, equalTo: "Ratboys") print("Searching artist Ratboys") let artistAlbums = try! await artistAlbumRequest.response() let name = artistAlbums.items.first!.title let id = artistAlbums.items.first!.id let end = Date() print("It took \(end.timeIntervalSince1970 - start.timeIntervalSince1970) to complete the artist request. \(artistAlbums.items.count) returned") print(artistAlbums.items) let start2 = Date() print("Searching by title: \(name)") var albumNameRequest = MusicLibraryRequest<Album>.init() albumNameRequest.filter(matching: \.title, equalTo: name) let nameAlbum = try! await albumNameRequest.response() let end2 = Date() print("It took \(end2.timeIntervalSince1970 - start2.timeIntervalSince1970) to complete this request") print(nameAlbum.items) print("Searching by ID") let start3 = Date() var albumIDRequest = MusicLibraryRequest<Album>.init() albumIDRequest.filter(matching: \.id, equalTo: id) let idalbum = try! await albumIDRequest.response() let end3 = Date() print("It took \(end3.timeIntervalSince1970 - start3.timeIntervalSince1970) to complete this request") print(idalbum.items) Awaiting the three requests takes 0.085, 0.019, and 0.102 seconds respectively on iOS. However, they take 7.10, 0.1, and 3.3 seconds on macOS. The second one only returns so quickly because of a bug where matching on title returns no results (see FB13094588) This makes it very difficult to provide a good experience when starting music playback, because it takes several seconds between the user selecting an album and it starting.

Thanks to the MusicKit team for addressing FB12301908 and FB12301718, but I'm afraid I've discovered even more issues that make MusicLibraryRequest<Album> difficult/impossible to use on macOS. Each of these issues is occurring on Sonoma seed 7 and Xcode 15 beta 8. FB13094022 - MusicLibraryRequest crashes when no filters are applied with error about MPModelGenre The following code crashes the app when run against my library (consisting of Apple Music catalog and self-added music) on macOS or Mac Catalyst: var libraryRequest = MusicLibraryRequest<Album>.init() let albums = try! await libraryRequest.response() The error is as follows: <NSXPCConnection: 0x6000023bc460> connection to service with pid 4331 named com.apple.amp.library.framework: Exception caught during invocation of reply block to message 'performLibraryRequest:withReply:'. Exception: No identifiers for model class: MPModelGenre from source: (null) ( 0 CoreFoundation 0x000000018ebb08c0 __exceptionPreprocess + 176 1 libobjc.A.dylib 0x000000018e6a9eb4 objc_exception_throw + 60 2 Foundation 0x000000018fcf718c -[NSCalendarDate initWithCoder:] + 0 3 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be7f3e20 -[MPBaseEntityTranslator _objectForPropertySet:source:context:] + 392 4 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be7f41f8 -[MPBaseEntityTranslator _objectForRelationshipKey:propertySet:source:context:] + 296 5 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be7f4088 __63-[MPBaseEntityTranslator _objectForPropertySet:source:context:]_block_invoke_2 + 76 6 CoreFoundation 0x000000018eafe6f4 __NSDICTIONARY_IS_CALLING_OUT_TO_A_BLOCK__ + 24 7 CoreFoundation 0x000000018eafe5bc -[__NSDictionaryI enumerateKeysAndObjectsWithOptions:usingBlock:] + 268 8 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be7f3fdc __63-[MPBaseEntityTranslator _objectForPropertySet:source:context:]_block_invoke + 436 9 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be82c5c4 -[MPModelObject initWithIdentifiers:block:] + 184 10 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be7f3d80 -[MPBaseEntityTranslator _objectForPropertySet:source:context:] + 232 11 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be7f30e0 -[MPBaseEntityTranslator objectForPropertySet:source:context:] + 32 12 MediaPlayer 0x00000001be8becbc __47-[MPModeliTunesLibraryRequestOperation execute]_block_invoke + 1032 13 iTunesLibrary 0x00000001c2de3584 iTunesLibrary + 83332 14 CoreFoundation 0x000000018eb1c144 __invoking___ + 148 15 CoreFoundation 0x000000018eb1bfbc -[NSInvocation invoke] + 428 16 Foundation 0x000000018fc06698 __NSXPCCONNECTION_IS_CALLING_OUT_TO_REPLY_BLOCK__ + 16 17 Foundation 0x000000018fc04d18 -[NSXPCConnection _decodeAndInvokeReplyBlockWithEvent:sequence:replyInfo:] + 520 18 Foundation 0x000000018fc04674 __88-[NSXPCConnection _sendInvocation:orArguments:count:methodSignature:selector:withProxy:]_block_invoke_3 + 188 19 libxpc.dylib 0x000000018e788034 _xpc_connection_reply_callout + 116 20 libxpc.dylib 0x000000018e787f2c _xpc_connection_call_reply_async + 80 21 libdispatch.dylib 0x000000010534ebcc _dispatch_client_callout3 + 20 22 libdispatch.dylib 0x0000000105373e0c _dispatch_mach_msg_async_reply_invoke + 400 23 libdispatch.dylib 0x0000000105357ae8 _dispatch_lane_serial_drain + 368 24 libdispatch.dylib 0x0000000105358e00 _dispatch_lane_invoke + 468 25 libdispatch.dylib 0x000000010536877c _dispatch_root_queue_drain_deferred_wlh + 652 26 libdispatch.dylib 0x0000000105367a54 _dispatch_workloop_worker_thread + 444 27 libsystem_pthread.dylib 0x00000001050abd9c _pthread_wqthread + 288 28 libsystem_pthread.dylib 0x00000001050b3ab4 start_wqthread + 8 ) FB13094588 - MusicLibraryRequest filtered by .title, equalTo returns blank The following code returns no results on macOS and MacCatalyst but successfully returns albums on iOS: var albumNameRequest = MusicLibraryRequest<Album>.init() albumNameRequest.filter(matching: \.title, equalTo: "The Window") let nameAlbums = try! await albumNameRequest.response() It returns no results whether I'm providing a string myself, or using the .title property of an Album I've already fetched

Now that's a mouthful! As of iOS 17 seed 5 and continuing into seed 6, an issue was introduced where default Navigation Bar and Tab Bar behavior breaks when a View is made up of a ScrollView with another ScrollView as the safeAreaInset. This View renders correctly using the code below, with the Navigation Bar and Tab Bar taking on a material effect when there is content behind it (screenshot 1). However, uncommenting out the ScrollView(.horizontal) so it's active causes the Nav Bar and Tab Bars to be fully transparent (screenshot 2): TabView { NavigationStack { ScrollView(.vertical) { LazyVStack { ForEach(0...100, id: \.self) { _ in Color(uiColor: UIColor.red) } } } .safeAreaInset(edge: .top, content: { //ScrollView(.horizontal) { HStack { Color.red Color.pink Color.yellow } // } .frame(maxWidth: .infinity) .frame(height: 44) }) .navigationTitle("Tab 1") .navigationBarTitleDisplayMode(.inline) }.tabItem { Label("One", systemImage: "bolt") } I have tried various combinations of the new scrollLayoutTarget() and related modifiers, but I haven’t been able to find a way to have the nav and tab bars maintain their functionality if the Horizontal ScrollView is enabled. This behavior seems like it’s supposed to be supported, because it’s one of the examples featured n this year’s WWDC session “Beyond scroll views” (at 12:34). It is also worth noting that this issue occurs whether the View is wrapped in a TabView or not. Without the TabView the problem presents the same in the Navigation Bar. I have submitted this issue as FB12983586

I'm running into a couple of breaking issues with AppIntents for which I just submitted feedbacks. I figured I'd post them on the forum too for good measure. FB12701143 - @IntentParameterDependency causing crashes in all AppIntents with Entity Queries on iOS 16 I have a pre-existing AppIntent with its own EntityQuery that works just fine on iOS 16. I've built a totally separate intent only available in iOS 17 that makes use of a new entity and a new query using @IntentParameterDependency, but now the original intent crashes after building and running the app on an iOS 16 device with the latest Xcode beta. The line it crashes on is the initializer of the iOS 17-only EntityQuery, even though 1) it shouldn't be able to see it and 2) that EntityQuery isn't involved in the crashing intent. This breaks significant functionality in my AppIntents, and I'm hoping this is a bug rather than a framework limitation. The feedback includes a sample project, crash log, and sysdiagnose. FB12701491 - iOS 17-only CustomIntentMigratedAppIntent stops SiriKit intent equivalent from working on iOS 16 I have a SiriKit intent in my app that I was not able to convert to an AppIntent until iOS 17 because it makes use of an @IntentParameterDependency. However, even though the new AppIntent version is marked as only available in iOS 17 and above, once I conform it to CustomIntentMigratedAppIntent and provide the old intent’s class name, it stops working on iOS 16 devices with an error that the shortcut is unavailable on that device. The CustomIntentMigratedAppIntent should respect the iOS 17 availability annotation and leave the SiriKit intent alone since its migrated replacement isn’t available on iOS 16. The feedback includes a sample project illustrating the issue.

As of the latest builds of both iOS 16.6 and iOS 17.0, playing albums from a users library using ApplicationMusicPlayer plays the songs on that album out of order. This is a dealbreaker for my app, and I’ve had to revert back to the Media Player framework for reliable behavior. If I fetch an album from a MusicLibraryRequest and load it into the queue using the API introduced in 16.4, init(album:startingAt:)., it starts at track 1 but then plays the rest of the tracks in random order. This happens whether skipping tracks or letting them play through. The shuffleMode of the player is .off. The issue does not occur with albums fetched from the Apple Music catalog and loaded using that same API, nor does it occur for MPMediaItemCollections loaded into an applicationQueuePlayer via a queue descriptor. I've submitted this issue as FB12495051 and provided a sysdiagnose. Please let me know if I can provide any other information.

ApplicationMusicPlayer is available on the Mac! 🎉🎉🎉 Enormous thanks to @JoeKun and the team. I've already gotten my app up and running through Catalyst, and I've successfully played music! I also got some timeouts, but that was happening on my phone a lot that day too, so maybe my local CDN was just having a bad day. I wanted to ask this question in a lab this week, but the timing didn't work out: Do you expect the experience to be the same using ApplicationMusicPlayer on a Catalyst vs a macOS target? I'm hoping to reuse much of my iPad app and go the Catalyst route, but I wanted to double check that the new support wasn't just for macOS.

I’m unable to use the .searchScopes modifier to add a segmented Picker to my search bar as of developer beta 6. It will not display whether I’m using a NavigationStack, NavigationSplitView, or NavigationView. Has anyone had any luck using this modifier? This simple code will demonstrate the problem. struct ContentView: View {     @State var searchText: String = ""     @State var searchScope: String = "Scope 1"         let data = Array(0..<20)     var body: some View {         NavigationStack {             List {                 ForEach(data, id:\.self) { item in                    Text("\(item)")                 }             }             .searchable(text: $searchText)             .searchScopes($searchScope, scopes: {                     Text("Scope 1")                     Text("Scope 2")             })         }     } } I've submitted this as FB11298015

I have been spending the last several weeks implementing NSPersistentCloudKitContainer in my app, and it is most of the way there. Unfortunately, I keep running into an issue where after several days of successful syncing between devices, each device begins to crash after about a minute of use, repeatedly. The crash report points to a SQL thread doing things with the CoreData and CloudKit frameworks — none of my code whatsoever. It is the typical “CPU:  48 seconds cpu time over 58 seconds (82% cpu average), exceeding limit of 80% cpu over 60 seconds” issue. If I run the devices hooked up to Xcode and debug, I see the thread spin up and the log shows it chugging through changed CKRecords it needs to import, just like normal. If I leave the devices hooked up to Xcode, they eventually make it through this huge job and the devices become usable again. Once one device is in this state, the problem also occurs on new devices trying to download from the cloud for the first time. I’ve attached a screenshot of the stacktrace of that thread in Instruments. I haven’t had any luck finding other people mentioning the system killing their app during a sync, so I’m kind of at a loss for what to do. It seems like the issue is occurring in a job that the NSPersistentCloudKitContainer is managing on my behalf and I haven’t been able to figure out a way to configure a timeout or anything.   Has anyone experienced this? I’m not sure what to do if the chunks that NSPersistentCloudKitContainer breaks up the import into are too large for the device to work through before the system kills the app. I’d appreciate any ideas or insights. Please let me know if any other information would be helpful. Thanks!

I'm very excited about the new MusicLibrary API, but after a couple of days of playing around with it, I have to say that I find the implementation of filtering MusicLibraryRequests a little confusing. MPMediaQuery has a fairly extensive list of predicates that can be applied, including string and persistentID comparisons for artist, album artist genre, and more. It also lets you filter on an item’s title. MusicLibraryRequests let you filter on the item’s ID, or on its MusicKit Artist and Genre relationships. To me, this seems like it adds an extra step.  With an MPMediaQuery, if I wanted to fetch every album by a given artist, I’d apply an MPMediaPropertyPredicate looking at MPMediaItemPropertyAlbumArtist and compare the string. It was also easy to change the MPMediaPredicateComparison to .contains to match more widely. If I wanted to surface albums by “Aesop Rock” or “Aesop Rock & Blockhead,” I could use that. In the MusicLibraryRequest implementation, it looks like I need to perform a MusicLibraryRequest<Artist> first in order to get the Artist objects. There’s no filter for the name property, so if I don’t have their IDs, I’ve got to use filter(text:). From there, I can take the results of that request and apply them to my MusicLibraryRequest<Album> using the filter(matching:memberOf) function.  I could use filter(text:) on the MusicLibraryRequest<Album>, but that filters across multiple properties (title and artistName?) and is less precise than defining the actual property I want to match against. I think my ideal version of the MusicLibraryRequest API would offer something like filter(matching:equalTo:) or filter(matching:contains:) that worked off of KeyPaths rather than relationships. That seems more intuitive to me. I’m not saying we need every property from every filterable MPMediaItemProperty key, but I’d love to be able to do it on title, artistName, and other common metadata. That might look something like: filter(matching: \.title, contains: “Abbey Road”) filter(matching: \.artistName, equalTo: “Between The Buried And Me”) I noticed that filter(text:) is case insensitive, which is awesome, and something I’ve wanted for a long time in MPMediaPropertyPredicate. As a bonus, it would be great if a KeyPath based filter API supported a case sensitivity flag. This is less of a problem when dealing with Apple Music catalog content, but users’ libraries are a harsh environment, and you might have an artist “Between The Buried And Me” and one called “Between the Buried and Me.” It would be great to get albums from both with something like: filter(matching: \.artistName, equalTo: “Between The Buried And Me”, caseSensitive: false)  I've submitted the above as FB10185685. I also submitted another feedback this morning regarding filter(text:) and repeating text as FB10184823. My last wishlist item for this API (for the time being!) is exposing the MPMediaItemPropertyAlbumPersistentID as an available filter attribute. I know, I know… hear me out. If you take a look at the other thread I made today, you’ll see that due to missing metadata in MusicKit, I still have some use cases where I need to be able to reference an MPMediaItem and might need to fetch its containing MPMediaItemCollection to get at other tracks on the album. It would be nice to seamlessly be able to fetch the MPMediaItemCollection or the library Album using a shared identifier, especially when it comes to being able to play the album in MusicKit’s player rather than Media Player’s.  I've submitted that list bit as FB10185789 Thanks for bearing with my walls of text today. Keep up the great work!

As the summer continues, I have been diving deeper and deeper into MusicKit, largely with great results. A few issues have arisen that I've outlined here, feedbacks already filed and numbers included here. All of this happens on the lasted developer beta and latest Xcode beta. Thanks! FB10967343 - Setting the queue with library and non-library items at the same time doesn't work correctly In my app, I am working on a feature that lets a user shuffle songs from a collection of albums that may or may not be in their library. However, I’ve discovered an issue where the queue does not seem to work correctly when mixing these types. I’ve attempted to load ApplicationMusicPlayer by creating a Queue and to load applicationQueuePlayer using a MPMusicPlayerPlayParametersQueueDescriptor, but the same issue occurs each time. The queue is able to play songs from the same source, but if it’s been playing a library song and tries to move to a non-library song, the queue stops.  The first thing I do is pick random songs from each album, using a MusicLibraryRequest or a MusicCatalogResourceRequest as appropriate, then taking a randomElement() from the ensuing MusicItemCollection for the album.  I append each track to an array, which I then cast to MusicItemCollection so I’ve now got a MusicItemCollection consisting of the tracks I want. If I’m in MusicKit land, I simply set the queue as follows:  player.queue = ApplicationMusicPlayer.Queue(for: tracks) It takes a bit more doing in MediaPlayer, but in theory this should also work, right?    do {         let paramObjects = tracks.compactMap {             $0.playParameters         }         let params = try paramObjects.map({try JSONEncoder().encode($0)}) let dicts = try params.compactMap {               try JSONSerialization.jsonObject(with: $0, options: []) as? [String:Any]           }           let finalParams = dicts.compactMap {                 MPMusicPlayerPlayParameters(dictionary: $0)             } let descriptor = MPMusicPlayerPlayParametersQueueDescriptor(playParametersQueue: finalParams) mediaPlayer.setQueue(with: descriptor) } catch { print(error) } In either case, the following issue occurs: say that I end up with a queue made up of one library song, then one non-library song. The player will play just the first song, then it acts as if the queue has ended. Say that it has two non-library songs, then one library song. Just the two non-library songs play. Indeed, printing queue.entries shows just the number of items that were from the same source type. FB10967076 - Publishing changes from background thread error when inserting queue items When using the .insert method on ApplicationMusicPlayer.Queue on the last iOS 16 and Xcode betas, it returns a “Publishing changes from background thread” error even though the function I’m doing in is marked as a @MainActor and the stacktace indicates it was on the main thread. FB10967277 - song.with([.albums], preferredSource: .library) generates thousands of lines of EntityQueries in the console I’ve noticed that when using the preferredSource: .library when requesting additional properties on a library item creates ~6,000 of “EntityQuery” entries in the console, all in the span of a second. This doesn’t seem to be leading to any major performance issues, but it sure seems like something isn't right. let request = MusicLibraryRequest<Song>.init() do { let response = try await request.response() guard let song = response.items.first else { return } let songWithAlbums = try await song.with([.albums], preferredSource: .library) } catch { print(error) } generates the following output (except... 6,000 of them) 2022-07-31 13:02:07.729003-0400 MusicKitFutzing[9405:2192606] [EntityQuery] Finished fetching results in 0s 2022-07-31 13:02:07.729047-0400 MusicKitFutzing[9405:2192605] [EntityQuery] Finished executing query in 0.00100017s 2022-07-31 13:02:07.729202-0400 MusicKitFutzing[9405:2192611] [EntityQuery] Finished executing query in 0s 2022-07-31 13:02:07.729240-0400 MusicKitFutzing[9405:2192605] [EntityQuery] Finished fetching results in 0s