Macbook 16 Clamshell + External Display Bug

I use my macbook 16 with an external display (lg 4k 32'') in clamshell mode.

It was fine until I updated from 10.15.4 to 10.15.5. Everything looks very laggy: cursor, window animations, video, everything.

Whenever I open the lid and use both monitors, it comes back to normal. But whenever I try to go back to clamshell mode, it lags.

My other workstation has the same monitor but it's still in 10.15.4, so I'm not updating that machine until this bug gets fixed!

I was reading some forums and it looks like an older version of macOS had a bug similar to this one. Another user claimed that he/she could go back using Time Machine, but as I use another software to only backup my work files, I can't test it out.


Anyway, in short, if you have a setup like mine DO NOT update to 10.15.5!

When I saw the new beta 2 update from apple today it gave me some hope (I didn't have beta 1 installed). But after work I updated to the new beta and realised it doesn't fix this issue.


I don't understand how apple can roll a public version with a bug like this, when (I'm just assuming) many developers probably use Macbooks hooked to external monitors at work and at the end of the day take the computer to go.


I'm not even considering reinstalling the whole OS, just in case someone suggests that. It's not a major issue to use the macbook open next to the external monitor. It's a incovenience, sure, but not worth reinstaling the whole system just to try if it works.

I also tried connecting the display over different ports and different cables. Same result. As it was right after the update, I'm 99% sure that's the cause.


Hope my long text help someone out there.

Best,

Pedro.

It has probably changed the refresh rate. I have the same issue on my 2018 MBPro. I had to resort to plugging the display only on the left side ports, even though before this update the monitor always worked fine. Try this go to System Preferences > Displays, then hold down the Option key and click the "Scaled" radio button. There should be a drop down to show Refresh Rates. If the drop down is missing then click on "Show low resolution modes".

On my system for no reason at all it goes to 30hz instead of the native 75hz. Sometimes it lets me change it, sometimes it doesn't.
Another tip is to plug the monitor and power into the right hand side ports.

If you plug them into the left ports your machine will generate heat near some sensors on the left side, causing a kernel_task process with high usage to appear in your Activity Monitor. This is a throttle and can cause all kinds of weird issues.

I’m having good luck with clamshell and external monitor now that I made this change. I’m running 10.15.5 on the base model 2019 16” MacBook Pro.
Please report this issue with Feedback Assistant.
Macbook 16 Clamshell + External Display Bug
 
 
Q