2020 Forums Wishlist/Feature Request Thread

We are excited to see the new forums! Here is an evolving list of feature requests and wishes. (Please post additional requests on this thread)

Feature Requests

  • Parse HTML in summaries

    • Example: Display > instead of >

  • Tag list

  • Sort results by most recent, most votes, most relevant.

  • List of most recent posts globally. When a developer wants to kill some time, it would be nice to see what people are asking. Similar features exist on StackOverflow and HackerNews.

  • Ability to see all of your responses. We can currently see a count, but not the actual posts. It would be nice to know if someone answered a followup.

  • Ability to rename profile.

  • Signatures

  • Polls

Political Requests

  • Users need to be able to criticize or vent about Apple or Apple products without the fear of getting their developer accounts banned. If Apple can clarify that what developers say on the forums will not negatively effect their apps or company's apps, it will go a long way towards moving the conversation from independent forums/SO/slacks and back to the official forums.

  • Year-round Apple Engineer engagement. The forums will die/lose respect if we only get serious engagement a few weeks in June.

Thank you Apple, I hope these Forums become an amazing resource!




Post not yet marked as solved Up vote post of shanecowherd Down vote post of shanecowherd
1.5k views
Posted by
shanecowherd
Reply
Add a Comment

Replies

Hello, I think the best place to send Apple feedbacks is through their dedicated website: https://feedbackassistant.apple.com/welcome
Thank you and I agree with what you are suggesting!
Posted by
MarcoCarnevali
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of MarcoCarnevali Down vote reply of MarcoCarnevali
Add a Comment
Actually, it is suggested to use the feedback assistant or a post on this forum for feedback. We only have to add "Forums Feedback" as a tag so everything is fine with this thread.

Now to the suggestions by @shanecowherd. I especially agree with point 3, 4 and 5.
The tag list named in point 2 can be found here.

Now to my wishes:

  • Mail notification when somebody replies to your question

  • This forum embed in the Apple Developer app

Posted by
Maci
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of Maci Down vote reply of Maci
Add a Comment
I would like to be able to edit my questions (there's no button)! And your profile page is rarely refreshed -- I posted a couple questions yesterday and so far only the first one has shown up. It would also be nice to see the upvote/downvote count.

Some links are restricted too. There seems to be a whitelist -- I can't link to Hacking With Swift or raw.github.com.

This URL can't be included in your post. Please remove it to continue.

And for some reason, links that include '%' get an auto-generated '25' after each of them. For example:
https://github.com/zjohnzheng/DeveloperAssets/blob/master/Shot%202020-06-19%20at%201.09.00%20PM.png
when pressed, results in a 404.

That's because the Forums added '25' in front of every '%'.
https://github.com/zjohnzheng/DeveloperAssets/blob/master/Shot%25202020-06-19%2520at%25201.09.00%2520PM.png

The search functionality is also pretty bad. I second your request of sorting results "by most recent, most votes, most relevant."




Posted by
ahzzheng
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of ahzzheng Down vote reply of ahzzheng
Add a Comment
Update: I'm now able to edit a post that I made 10 minutes ago, but I still can't edit those published before that.

Edit: The Forums Support says:

You can edit any content that you’ve authored for up to one hour after posting.



Posted by
ahzzheng
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of ahzzheng Down vote reply of ahzzheng
Add a Comment

List of most recent posts globally. When a developer wants to kill some time, it would be nice to see what people are asking.

These forums are based on the Apple Support Communities forums, at least from a technical perspective. Apple Support Communities has a "Subscriptions" feature that would really be useful here.

Ability to see all of your responses. We can currently see a count, but not the actual posts. It would be nice to know if someone answered a followup.

Apple Support Communities supports this too, albeit a bit awkwardly.

Signatures

These can be easily abused by spammers.

Polls

That's a can-o-worms. Not going to happen.

Users need to be able to criticize or vent about Apple or Apple products

You've got the rest of the internet for that. Can't we have just one safe space where we can talk code and tech without politics?

Year-round Apple Engineer engagement. The forums will die/lose respect if we only get serious engagement a few weeks in June.

Apple's Developer forums have always had engagement from Apple engineers. And that was when the forums were pretty much a wasteland. If more real developers used the forums as a resource, then I'm sure Apple will devote even more support resources to them.
Posted by
john daniel
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of john daniel Down vote reply of john daniel
Add a Comment
It would be good to have a few search operators like StackOverflow. Besides dates (which has already been mentioned) it's nice to search for things with or without answers. If you want to help others and answer questions, you can say, for example, "Show me questions about Swift in the last year with no accepted answer". Something like:

[Swift] created:2019-2020 accepted:no
Posted by
rnikander
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of rnikander Down vote reply of rnikander
Add a Comment
Dear shanecowherd,

Thank you for making this thread.
The following feature also I would want it.

Sort results by most recent, most votes, most relevant.

I think that it is helpful for some people to just specify in the help page how topics are arranged.
Finally, i hope this forum thrives.
Posted by
hiroakit
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of hiroakit Down vote reply of hiroakit
Add a Comment
I'd like to be able to follow threads to get on-forum notifications about new replies to them. This should also allow users to say in their account settings that they want posting to a thread to automatically follow that same thread. (Maybe the latter's already implicit, though…?)
Posted by
RandomDSdevel
Post not yet marked as solved Up vote reply of RandomDSdevel Down vote reply of RandomDSdevel
Add a Comment