Hello! We have the same issue. And it's happening in Production as well.Actually this happens not only when redeeming subscription offer. You can try purchasing a regular subscription while current is still active. When you're downgrading subsription or cross-grading with dirreferent duration, you will still get 'You're all set' message but an error that transaction failed.I found this message from Apple staff (read Rich's answer): https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/112663I don't know how to avoid this issue and it's very frustrating.