For people who've been experiencing this issue: There is a really stupid but 100% working fix. public extension View { func projectionOffset(x: CGFloat = 0, y: CGFloat = 0) -> some View { self.projectionOffset(.init(x: x, y: y)) } func projectionOffset(_ translation: CGPoint) -> some View { modifier(ProjectionOffsetEffect(translation: translation)) } } private struct ProjectionOffsetEffect: GeometryEffect { var translation: CGPoint var animatableData: CGPoint.AnimatableData { get { translation.animatableData } set { translation = .init(x: newValue.first, y: newValue.second) } } public func effectValue(size: CGSize) -> ProjectionTransform { .init(CGAffineTransform(translationX: translation.x, y: translation.y)) } } This will works perfectly with scoped animation. Text("Hello, world!") .animation(.default) { $0 .opacity(animate ? 1 : 0.2) // .offset(y: animate ? 0 : 100) // <-- DOESN'T WORKS!!! .projectionOffset(y: animate ? 0 : 100) // <-- WORKS!!! } I've spent the last 3 days trying to figure out why every other animatable modifier works fine with scoped animation but not offset(). turns out it can. it's just a bug in the implementation, which I don't understand the how, considering how simple the implementation is, but whatever. hope this helps! @calin

you're writing to think it doesn't make sense, because var body is doing some sort of meta programming with @ViewBuilder check out what @ViewBuilder does

Actually, i've been doing this on macOS target. (without mac catalyst) so no simulator. i don't think it's button style issue either, the example i shared is 100% reproducible, regardless of button style. it's just that .keyboardShortcut is keep calling "outdated" action, that already been replaced by button. also, as i wrote on original post, it works perfectly fine if i force rerender of button by changing label to use model.option