NavigationSplitView freezes

@SwiftyJoe Thanks for providing the project.

• Have identified where in their code issues are occurring.?
• Could you share the steps you have taken to debug the issue?
• Have you tried testing by replacing your data layer from CoreData to in-memory object to narrow down the cause of the issue ?

Please identify and share the troubleshooting and debugging steps you’ve taken to identify and resolve the issue. This would be an ideal starting point in debugging the issue you're experiencing. Thanks

@DTS Engineer Thanks for your answer.

To debug the issue I tried 2 different things:

FIRST: I changed the code from @State/@Observable back to @StateObject/ObservableObject today.

Instead of implementing the teamController as @State var teamController = TeamController() I used @StateObject var teamController = TeamController().

And instead of using @Observable class TeamController { var selectedTeam: Team? } I used class TeamController: ObservableObject{ @Published var selectedTeam: Team? }

Having the code like this, everything works fine and the NavigationSplitView does not freeze.

SECOND: Back-Button does not reset the teamController.selectedTeam to nil when using @State/@Observable

When tapping a team in the list-View, the tapped team will be set as teamController.selectedTeam. When tapping the back-Button after tapping a team, teamController.selectedTeam will not be set back to nil when my code uses @State/@Observable.

Conclusion

Depending on the usage of @State/@Observable or @StateObject/ObservableObject the NavigationSplitView seems to reset teamController.selectedTeam to nil or not. In my understanding of the @Obersvable-Macro it should make no difference? Am I using the @ObservableMacro wrong?

Today I removed code step by step to give you a more simpler project for the support and in addition tried to find which code may cause the problem. And I found the following:

The code is back to @State and @Observable.

In the file "TeamAndPlayerView.swift" I changed

detail: {
            if playerController.selectedPlayer != nil {
                PlayerDetailView(teamController: teamController, playerController: playerController, selectedPlayer: playerController.selectedPlayer!)
            } else {
                ContentUnavailableView("No Player", systemImage: "person.fill", description: Text("Please add or select a player to see the details."))
            }

into

detail: {
           EmptyView()
        }

Having the code like this, everything works fine and you can tap a team, go back again and tap the team again as often as you want. The teamController.selectedTeam is set back to nil correctly.

When implementing EmptyView() within the if clause, the NavigationSplitView sometimes freezes when repeatedly tapping into a team and then going back.

detail: {
            if playerController.selectedPlayer != nil {
                EmptyView()
            } else {
                ContentUnavailableView("No Player", systemImage: "person.fill", description: Text("Please add or select a player to see the details."))
            }
        }

Note: I was unable to create a more minimalistic code example because the error appears to be somewhere in the detail section.

It appears that the list selection does not reliably reset to nil when tapping the “back” button.

List(selection: $teamController.selectedTeam) {.....}

To address this, I added an onAppear modifier to force the list selection to reset to nil.

List(selection: $teamController.selectedTeam) {.....}
.onAppear {teamController.seletedTeam = nil}

This resolved the issue for both the team and player lists.

However, it would be helpful if someone could explain why the list selection doesn’t automatically reset to nil when tapping the back button.