Issue with SceneStorage in ViewModifer, but not in View

Question

Created Mar ’24

Replies 3

Boosts 0

Participants 2

Hello, Awhile ago I'd refactored my code to have @SceneStorage in a ViewModifier and not on a View. In Xcode 15.3, I see a runtime-only warning:

SceneStorage is only for use with SwiftUI App Lifecycle. This will become a fatal error in a future release.
Accessing a SceneStorage value outside of being installed on a View. This will always return the default value.
Creating a Binding to SceneStorage value outside of being installed on a View. This will result in a constant Binding of the default value and will not update.

I'd used a ViewModifier to encapsulate this code. Why is that different than a View?

If you are interested you can see an example here: https://github.com/bolsinga/site/blob/ffbedd7fb134675496f529cf62484ceb9b79d360/Sources/Site/Music/UI/ArchiveStorageModifier.swift#L15

Thanks for any tips!

Answered by Bolsinga in 801871022

With the same code, the warning is gone in Xcode 15.4, where I target x.5 releases of iOS and macOS.

Boost

Answer 1

MobileTen OP

Mar ’24

Just as the message states, it is to be only used within a SwiftUI View where the context of a scene exists.

0

Answer 2

Bolsinga OP

Mar ’24

I'm sorry; I see the message. I do not understand why the ViewModifier (which knows the View) is different in this manner than the View itself. Thanks.

0

Answer 3

Bolsinga OP

Aug ’24

Accepted Answer

With the same code, the warning is gone in Xcode 15.4, where I target x.5 releases of iOS and macOS.

0