Can't add Mac M1 to provisioning profile

So I've already been able to do this for a different Mac M1. I don't know exactly how I got it to show up other than added the device to the Device list and then I was able to select the device when I go into the Provisioning Profile. No problems, but then I tried doing this for another M1 device (macbook) and for the life of me I can't get it to show up so I can select it in the Provisioning Profile. I've already added it to the Device list and even successfully created developer and distribution certs from it after logging in with a developer account different than before since this is a different developer's laptop I was walking him through. The original account I used has "admin" role. Could that be the difference? "Include Mac Devices" is toggled on in the Provisioning Profile.