Post

Replies

Boosts

Views

Activity

Causes of disordered dictionary in Swift
Everyone knows that dictionaries in swift are unordered collections, there is no problem with that. I've noticed some behavior that I can't explain and hope someone can help me. The first variant We have a very simple code: struct Test { let dict = [1: “1”, 2: “2”, 3: “3”, 4: “4”, 5: “5”] func test() { for i in dict { print(i) } } } If you call test() several times in a row, the output to the console on my computer looks something like this: (key: 5, value: “5”) (key: 1, value: “1”) (key: 2, value: “2”) (key: 3, value: “3”) (key: 4, value: “4”) (key: 2, value: “2”) (key: 3, value: “3”) (key: 1, value: “1”) (key: 4, value: “4”) (key: 5, value: “5”) (key: 1, value: “1”) (key: 3, value: “3”) (key: 2, value: “2”) (key: 5, value: “5”) (key: 4, value: “4”) At each new for loop we get a random order of elements It seemed logical to me, because a dictionary is an unordered collection and this is correct behavior. However The second variant the same code on my colleague's computer, but in the console we see something like this: (key: 2, value: “2”) (key: 3, value: “3”) (key: 1, value: “1”) (key: 4, value: “4”) (key: 5, value: “5”) (key: 2, value: “2”) (key: 3, value: “3”) (key: 1, value: “1”) (key: 4, value: “4”) (key: 5, value: “5”) (key: 2, value: “2”) (key: 3, value: “3”) (key: 1, value: “1”) (key: 4, value: “4”) (key: 5, value: “5”) always, within the same session, we get the same order in print(i) We didn't use Playground, within which there may be differences, but a real project. swift version 5+ we tested on Xcode 14+, 15+ (at first I thought it was because the first version had 14 and the second version had 15, but then a third colleague with Xcode 15 had the behavior from the first scenario) we did a lot of checks, several dozens of times and always got that on one computer random output of items to the console, and in another case disordered only in the first output to the console Thanks
4
0
154
1w